feat: token streaming for orchestrator final response

Switches the orchestrator's final response from a fire-and-wait model to a
live SSE stream so text appears token-by-token as the model generates it.

- llm_client: complete() gains token_sink param; anthropic_api backend uses
  client.messages.stream(); local backend uses httpx SSE streaming; non-streaming
  backends (claude_cli, gemini_cli) emit the full text as one chunk
- orchestrator_engine + openai_orchestrator: token_sink threaded through run(),
  _run_from_contents(), _claude_handoff(), and _run_from_messages()
- routers/orchestrator: each job gets an asyncio.Queue; _on_progress and
  _token_sink write progress/token events to it; _finalize_job emits done,
  error handler emits error, confirmation gate emits confirm; new GET
  /orchestrate/{job_id}/stream SSE endpoint with 20s keepalive
- app.js: _doOrchestrate switches from 2s poll loop to EventSource; thinking
  bubble converts to a streaming message on first token; auto-scroll while
  streaming; confirm/error/done events handled; finalization unchanged

Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.6 <noreply@anthropic.com>

cortex/llm_client.py

@@ -53,6 +53,7 @@ async def complete(
     slot: str | None = None,
     max_tokens: int = 2048,
     attachment: dict | None = None,
+    token_sink=None,  # async (str) -> None; if set, stream tokens as they arrive
 ) -> tuple[str, str]:
     """
     Returns (response_text, actual_backend_used).
@@ -98,7 +99,8 @@ async def complete(
     fallback = _FALLBACK.get(primary, "claude")
 
     try:
-        response = await _dispatch(primary, system_prompt, messages, resolved_cfg, attachment=attachment)
+        response = await _dispatch(primary, system_prompt, messages, resolved_cfg,
+                                   attachment=attachment, token_sink=token_sink)
         return response, primary
     except Exception as e:
         err_str = str(e)
@@ -109,7 +111,7 @@ async def complete(
             logger.error("%s failed (no fallback — model explicitly configured): %s", primary, e)
             raise
         logger.warning("%s failed (%s) — falling back to %s", primary, e, fallback)
-        response = await _dispatch(fallback, system_prompt, messages, None)
+        response = await _dispatch(fallback, system_prompt, messages, None, token_sink=token_sink)
         return response, fallback
 
 
@@ -119,14 +121,24 @@ async def _dispatch(
     messages: list[dict],
     model_cfg: dict | None,
     attachment: dict | None = None,
+    token_sink=None,
 ) -> str:
     if backend == "gemini":
-        return await _gemini(system_prompt, messages)
+        text = await _gemini(system_prompt, messages)
-    if backend == "local":
+    elif backend == "local":
-        return await _local(system_prompt, messages, model_cfg, attachment=attachment)
+        if token_sink:
-    if backend == "anthropic_api":
+            return await _local_streaming(token_sink, system_prompt, messages, model_cfg)
-        return await _anthropic_api(system_prompt, messages, model_cfg)
+        text = await _local(system_prompt, messages, model_cfg, attachment=attachment)
-    return await _claude(system_prompt, messages, model_cfg)
+    elif backend == "anthropic_api":
+        if token_sink:
+            return await _anthropic_api_streaming(token_sink, system_prompt, messages, model_cfg)
+        text = await _anthropic_api(system_prompt, messages, model_cfg)
+    else:
+        text = await _claude(system_prompt, messages, model_cfg)
+    # For non-streaming backends when token_sink is provided, emit the full text as one chunk.
+    if token_sink and text:
+        await token_sink(text)
+    return text
 
 
 def _fresh_claude_token() -> str | None:
@@ -302,6 +314,99 @@ async def _anthropic_api(system_prompt: str, messages: list[dict], model_cfg: di
     return text.strip()
 
 
+async def _anthropic_api_streaming(
+    token_sink, system_prompt: str, messages: list[dict], model_cfg: dict | None
+) -> str:
+    try:
+        import anthropic
+    except ImportError:
+        raise RuntimeError("anthropic SDK not installed — run: pip install 'anthropic>=0.40.0'")
+
+    cfg        = model_cfg or {}
+    api_key    = cfg.get("api_key", "")
+    model_name = cfg.get("model_name") or settings.default_model
+
+    if not api_key:
+        raise RuntimeError("No Anthropic API key — add one at /settings/models")
+
+    client = anthropic.AsyncAnthropic(api_key=api_key)
+    msgs   = [{"role": m["role"], "content": m["content"]} for m in messages]
+    kwargs: dict = {"model": model_name, "max_tokens": 4096, "messages": msgs}
+    if system_prompt:
+        kwargs["system"] = system_prompt
+
+    full_text = ""
+    async with client.messages.stream(**kwargs) as stream:
+        async for chunk in stream.text_stream:
+            await token_sink(chunk)
+            full_text += chunk
+
+    final_msg = await stream.get_final_message()
+    if final_msg.usage:
+        import usage_tracker
+        from persona import _user
+        asyncio.create_task(usage_tracker.record(
+            username=_user.get(),
+            backend="anthropic_api",
+            model_name=model_name,
+            prompt_tokens=final_msg.usage.input_tokens,
+            completion_tokens=final_msg.usage.output_tokens,
+        ))
+
+    return full_text.strip()
+
+
+async def _local_streaming(
+    token_sink, system_prompt: str, messages: list[dict], model_cfg: dict | None
+) -> str:
+    import httpx
+    import json as _json
+
+    cfg = model_cfg or {}
+    api_url   = cfg.get("api_url", "")
+    api_key   = cfg.get("api_key", "")
+    model     = cfg.get("model_name", "")
+    host_type = cfg.get("host_type", "openwebui")
+
+    if not api_url:
+        raise RuntimeError("local_api_url not configured")
+    if not model:
+        raise RuntimeError("local_model not configured")
+
+    chat_path = "/chat/completions" if host_type == "openai" else "/api/chat/completions"
+    url       = api_url.rstrip("/") + chat_path
+    headers: dict[str, str] = {"Authorization": f"Bearer {api_key}"} if api_key else {}
+
+    msgs: list[dict] = []
+    if system_prompt:
+        msgs.append({"role": "system", "content": system_prompt})
+    for m in messages:
+        msgs.append({"role": m["role"], "content": m["content"]})
+
+    payload = {"model": model, "messages": msgs, "stream": True}
+    full_text = ""
+
+    async with httpx.AsyncClient(timeout=settings.timeout_local) as client:
+        async with client.stream("POST", url, json=payload, headers=headers) as resp:
+            resp.raise_for_status()
+            async for line in resp.aiter_lines():
+                if not line or not line.startswith("data: "):
+                    continue
+                data_str = line[6:].strip()
+                if data_str == "[DONE]":
+                    break
+                try:
+                    chunk = _json.loads(data_str)
+                    delta = (chunk["choices"][0]["delta"].get("content") or "")
+                    if delta:
+                        await token_sink(delta)
+                        full_text += delta
+                except Exception:
+                    pass
+
+    return full_text.strip()
+
+
 async def _gemini(system_prompt: str, messages: list[dict]) -> str:
     # Gemini CLI spawns MCP child processes that keep stdout pipes open after responding.
     # start_new_session=True puts the whole tree in its own process group so

cortex/openai_orchestrator.py

@@ -53,6 +53,7 @@ async def run(
     risk_whitelist: list[str] | None = None,
     risk_blacklist: list[str] | None = None,
     on_progress=None,  # async (str) -> None; called with live status updates
+    token_sink=None,   # async (str) -> None; called with each response token
 ) -> OrchestratorResult:
     """
     Run a tool-enabled task using an OpenAI-compatible API.
@@ -119,6 +120,7 @@ async def run(
         confirm_deny=_confirm_deny,
         starting_round=0,
         on_progress=on_progress,
+        token_sink=token_sink,
     )
 
     if checkpoint:
@@ -310,6 +312,7 @@ async def _run_from_messages(
     starting_round: int = 0,
     tool_list: list[str] | None = None,
     on_progress=None,
+    token_sink=None,
 ) -> tuple[str, OrchestrateCheckpoint | None]:
     """
     Run the OpenAI ReAct loop from the current messages state.
@@ -425,6 +428,8 @@ async def _run_from_messages(
             if on_progress:
                 await on_progress("Generating response…")
             final_response = msg.content or ""
+            if token_sink and final_response:
+                await token_sink(final_response)
             logger.info(
                 "OpenAI orchestrator done after %d round(s). Tools used: %d",
                 round_num + 1, len(tool_call_log),

cortex/orchestrator_engine.py

@@ -121,6 +121,7 @@ async def run(
     risk_whitelist: list[str] | None = None,
     risk_blacklist: list[str] | None = None,
     on_progress=None,  # async (str) -> None; called with live status updates
+    token_sink=None,   # async (str) -> None; called with each response token
 ) -> OrchestratorResult:
     """
     Run the full orchestration loop for a task.
@@ -185,6 +186,7 @@ async def run(
         gemini_api_key=api_key,
         max_rounds=max_rounds,
         on_progress=on_progress,
+        token_sink=token_sink,
     )
 
     if checkpoint:
@@ -207,6 +209,7 @@ async def run(
         session_messages=session_messages,
         respond_with_claude=respond_with_claude,
         response_role=response_role,
+        token_sink=token_sink,
     )
 
 
@@ -270,6 +273,8 @@ async def resume(checkpoint: OrchestrateCheckpoint, confirmed: bool) -> Orchestr
         gemini_api_key=api_key,
         max_rounds=checkpoint.max_rounds,
     )
+    # Note: resume() doesn't have token_sink — the SSE stream endpoint is long-closed
+    # by the time a resumed job's final response is ready; polling fallback applies.
 
     if new_checkpoint:
         return OrchestratorResult(
@@ -312,6 +317,7 @@ async def _run_from_contents(
     tool_list: list[str] | None = None,
     max_rounds: int | None = None,
     on_progress=None,
+    token_sink=None,
 ) -> tuple[str, OrchestrateCheckpoint | None]:
     """
     Run the ReAct loop from the current contents state.
@@ -454,6 +460,7 @@ async def _claude_handoff(
     session_messages: list[dict] | None,
     respond_with_claude: bool,
     response_role: str,
+    token_sink=None,
 ) -> OrchestratorResult:
     if respond_with_claude:
         claude_prompt = _build_claude_prompt(task, tool_call_log, gemini_summary)
@@ -463,10 +470,13 @@ async def _claude_handoff(
             system_prompt=system_prompt,
             messages=messages,
             role=response_role,
+            token_sink=token_sink,
         )
     else:
         response_text = gemini_summary or "No information gathered."
         backend = "gemini"
+        if token_sink and response_text:
+            await token_sink(response_text)
 
     return OrchestratorResult(
         response=response_text,

cortex/routers/orchestrator.py

@@ -16,7 +16,8 @@ import platform
 import uuid
 from datetime import datetime, timezone
 
-from fastapi import APIRouter, HTTPException
+from fastapi import APIRouter, HTTPException, Request
+from fastapi.responses import StreamingResponse
 from pydantic import BaseModel
 
 from auth_utils import get_user_gemini_key, get_user_role, get_tool_policy, get_risk_policy
@@ -116,6 +117,7 @@ async def orchestrate(req: OrchestrateRequest) -> OrchestrateResponse:
         "progress": None,
         "_user": user,
         "_off_record": req.off_record,
+        "_event_queue": asyncio.Queue(),
     }
 
     async with _jobs_lock:
@@ -146,6 +148,45 @@ async def list_jobs() -> list[JobStatusResponse]:
     return [JobStatusResponse(**{k: v for k, v in j.items() if not k.startswith("_")}) for j in jobs]
 
 
+@router.get("/{job_id}/stream")
+async def stream_job(job_id: str, request: Request) -> StreamingResponse:
+    """SSE stream for a running job — emits progress, token, done, error, and confirm events."""
+    import json
+
+    async with _jobs_lock:
+        job = _jobs.get(job_id)
+    if job is None:
+        raise HTTPException(status_code=404, detail=f"Job {job_id} not found")
+
+    # If already complete/error, emit a single done/error event immediately.
+    if job["status"] == "complete":
+        async def _done_now():
+            yield f"data: {json.dumps({'type': 'done', 'response': job['response'], 'session_id': job.get('session_id'), 'backend': job.get('backend', ''), 'backend_label': job.get('backend_label', ''), 'host': job.get('host', ''), 'tool_calls': job.get('tool_calls')})}\n\n"
+        return StreamingResponse(_done_now(), media_type="text/event-stream")
+    if job["status"] == "error":
+        async def _err_now():
+            yield f"data: {json.dumps({'type': 'error', 'message': job.get('error', 'Unknown error')})}\n\n"
+        return StreamingResponse(_err_now(), media_type="text/event-stream")
+
+    queue: asyncio.Queue = job["_event_queue"]
+
+    async def generate():
+        yield 'data: {"type":"connected"}\n\n'
+        while True:
+            if await request.is_disconnected():
+                break
+            try:
+                event = await asyncio.wait_for(queue.get(), timeout=20)
+                yield f"data: {json.dumps(event)}\n\n"
+                if event["type"] in ("done", "error"):
+                    break
+                # For confirm events: keep listening — job will resume after user action.
+            except asyncio.TimeoutError:
+                yield 'data: {"type":"keepalive"}\n\n'
+
+    return StreamingResponse(generate(), media_type="text/event-stream")
+
+
 @router.post("/{job_id}/confirm", response_model=OrchestrateResponse)
 async def confirm_job(job_id: str) -> OrchestrateResponse:
     """Confirm a pending tool call — the blocked tool will execute and the job continues."""
@@ -201,8 +242,18 @@ async def _run_job(job_id: str, req: OrchestrateRequest, user: str) -> None:
 
     async def _on_progress(msg: str) -> None:
         async with _jobs_lock:
-            if job_id in _jobs:
+            if job_id not in _jobs:
-                _jobs[job_id]["progress"] = msg
+                return
+            _jobs[job_id]["progress"] = msg
+            q = _jobs[job_id].get("_event_queue")
+        if q:
+            await q.put({"type": "progress", "text": msg})
+
+    async def _token_sink(text: str) -> None:
+        async with _jobs_lock:
+            q = _jobs.get(job_id, {}).get("_event_queue")
+        if q:
+            await q.put({"type": "token", "text": text})
 
     try:
         from session_store import load as load_session, save as save_session, generate_session_id
@@ -248,6 +299,7 @@ async def _run_job(job_id: str, req: OrchestrateRequest, user: str) -> None:
                 risk_whitelist=risk_wl,
                 risk_blacklist=risk_bl,
                 on_progress=_on_progress,
+                token_sink=_token_sink,
             )
         else:
             gemini_key = (
@@ -271,6 +323,7 @@ async def _run_job(job_id: str, req: OrchestrateRequest, user: str) -> None:
                 risk_whitelist=risk_wl,
                 risk_blacklist=risk_bl,
                 on_progress=_on_progress,
+                token_sink=_token_sink,
             )
 
         if result.checkpoint:
@@ -289,8 +342,15 @@ async def _run_job(job_id: str, req: OrchestrateRequest, user: str) -> None:
                         "message": result.response,
                     },
                 })
+                q = _jobs[job_id].get("_event_queue")
             logger.info("Orchestrator job %s awaiting confirmation — %d tool(s) blocked",
                         job_id, len(result.checkpoint.pending_tools))
+            if q:
+                await q.put({
+                    "type": "confirm",
+                    "tools": result.checkpoint.pending_tools,
+                    "message": result.response,
+                })
             return
 
         await _finalize_job(job_id, result, session_id, req.task, history, off_record=req.off_record)
@@ -304,6 +364,9 @@ async def _run_job(job_id: str, req: OrchestrateRequest, user: str) -> None:
                 "completed_at": now,
                 "error": str(e),
             })
+            q = _jobs[job_id].get("_event_queue")
+        if q:
+            await q.put({"type": "error", "message": str(e)})
 
 
 async def _resume_job(
@@ -400,4 +463,15 @@ async def _finalize_job(
             "host": host,
             "gemini_summary": result.gemini_summary,
         })
+        q = _jobs[job_id].get("_event_queue")
     logger.info("Orchestrator job complete: %s (%d tool calls)", job_id, len(result.tool_calls))
+    if q:
+        await q.put({
+            "type": "done",
+            "response": result.response,
+            "session_id": session_id,
+            "backend": result.backend,
+            "backend_label": result.backend_label or "",
+            "host": host,
+            "tool_calls": result.tool_calls,
+        })

cortex/static/app.js

@@ -1475,68 +1475,79 @@
                 if (!res.ok) throw new Error(`HTTP ${res.status}`);
                 const { job_id } = await res.json();
 
-                // Poll until complete or stopped
+                // Stream events from the job via SSE
-                let job;
+                const job = await new Promise((resolve, reject) => {
-                while (true) {
+                    const es = new EventSource(`/orchestrate/${job_id}/stream`);
-                    if (activeController.signal.aborted) throw new DOMException('Aborted', 'AbortError');
+                    let streamingStarted = false;
+                    let accumulatedText = '';
 
-                    await new Promise(r => setTimeout(r, 2000));
+                    const abort = activeController.signal;
+                    abort.addEventListener('abort', () => { es.close(); reject(new DOMException('Aborted', 'AbortError')); });
 
-                    if (activeController.signal.aborted) throw new DOMException('Aborted', 'AbortError');
+                    es.onmessage = async (e) => {
+                        let event;
+                        try { event = JSON.parse(e.data); } catch { return; }
 
-                    const pollRes = await fetch(`/orchestrate/${job_id}`, {
+                        if (event.type === 'connected' || event.type === 'keepalive') return;
-                        signal: activeController.signal,
-                    });
-                    if (!pollRes.ok) throw new Error(`Poll failed: HTTP ${pollRes.status}`);
-                    job = await pollRes.json();
 
-                    if (job.status === 'queued' || job.status === 'running') {
+                        if (event.type === 'progress') {
-                        const prog = job.progress;
+                            if (!streamingStarted) thinkingDiv.textContent = `⚡ ${event.text}`;
-                        const n = job.tool_calls?.length || 0;
+                            return;
-                        if (prog) {
-                            thinkingDiv.textContent = `⚡ ${prog}`;
-                        } else {
-                            thinkingDiv.textContent = n
-                                ? `⚡ working… (${n} tool${n !== 1 ? 's' : ''} used)`
-                                : '⚡ working…';
                         }
-                        continue;
-                    }
 
-                    if (job.status === 'awaiting_confirmation') {
+                        if (event.type === 'token') {
-                        const pc = job.pending_confirmation || {};
+                            if (!streamingStarted) {
-                        const toolNames = (pc.tools || []).map(t => t.name).join(', ');
+                                streamingStarted = true;
-                        thinkingDiv.className = 'message assistant';
+                                thinkingDiv.className = 'message assistant';
-                        thinkingDiv.innerHTML = `<div class="confirm-gate">
+                                thinkingDiv.innerHTML = '';
-                            <p>${escapeHtml(pc.message || 'Confirm this action?')}</p>
+                            }
-                            <p class="confirm-tools">Tool${(pc.tools||[]).length !== 1 ? 's' : ''}: <code>${escapeHtml(toolNames)}</code></p>
+                            accumulatedText += event.text;
-                            <div class="confirm-actions">
+                            setMessageText(thinkingDiv, 'assistant', accumulatedText);
-                                <button class="confirm-btn">Confirm</button>
+                            thinkingDiv.scrollIntoView({ behavior: 'smooth', block: 'end' });
-                                <button class="deny-btn">Deny</button>
+                            return;
-                            </div>
+                        }
-                        </div>`;
 
-                        const confirmed = await new Promise(resolve => {
+                        if (event.type === 'confirm') {
-                            thinkingDiv.querySelector('.confirm-btn').onclick = () => resolve(true);
+                            const pc = event;
-                            thinkingDiv.querySelector('.deny-btn').onclick  = () => resolve(false);
+                            const toolNames = (pc.tools || []).map(t => t.name).join(', ');
-                        });
+                            thinkingDiv.className = 'message assistant';
+                            thinkingDiv.innerHTML = `<div class="confirm-gate">
+                                <p>${escapeHtml(pc.message || 'Confirm this action?')}</p>
+                                <p class="confirm-tools">Tool${(pc.tools||[]).length !== 1 ? 's' : ''}: <code>${escapeHtml(toolNames)}</code></p>
+                                <div class="confirm-actions">
+                                    <button class="confirm-btn">Confirm</button>
+                                    <button class="deny-btn">Deny</button>
+                                </div>
+                            </div>`;
+                            const confirmed = await new Promise(r => {
+                                thinkingDiv.querySelector('.confirm-btn').onclick = () => r(true);
+                                thinkingDiv.querySelector('.deny-btn').onclick  = () => r(false);
+                            });
+                            thinkingDiv.className = 'message assistant thinking';
+                            thinkingDiv.textContent = confirmed ? '⚡ confirmed — continuing…' : '⚡ denied — finishing…';
+                            streamingStarted = false;
+                            accumulatedText = '';
+                            const action = confirmed ? 'confirm' : 'deny';
+                            await fetch(`/orchestrate/${job_id}/${action}`, { method: 'POST' });
+                            return;
+                        }
 
-                        thinkingDiv.className = 'message assistant thinking';
+                        if (event.type === 'error') {
-                        thinkingDiv.textContent = confirmed ? '⚡ confirmed — continuing…' : '⚡ denied — finishing…';
+                            es.close();
+                            reject(new Error(event.message || 'Orchestrator failed'));
+                            return;
+                        }
 
-                        const action = confirmed ? 'confirm' : 'deny';
+                        if (event.type === 'done') {
-                        const resumeRes = await fetch(`/orchestrate/${job_id}/${action}`, {
+                            es.close();
-                            method: 'POST',
+                            // If we received tokens, the response is already rendered —
-                            signal: activeController.signal,
+                            // use accumulatedText; otherwise fall back to event.response.
-                        });
+                            resolve({ ...event, response: accumulatedText || event.response });
-                        if (!resumeRes.ok) throw new Error(`Resume failed: HTTP ${resumeRes.status}`);
+                        }
-                        continue;
+                    };
-                    }
 
-                    break;
+                    es.onerror = () => { es.close(); reject(new Error('Stream connection lost')); };
-                }
+                });
-
-                if (job.status === 'error') throw new Error(job.error || 'Orchestrator failed');
 
                 // Update session so this turn is part of the resumable history
                 if (job.session_id) {
@@ -1548,6 +1559,7 @@
                 const userHistIdx = currentHistory.length - 1; // pushed before fetch
                 attachHistoryControls(userMsgDiv, userHistIdx);
 
+                // If tokens streamed, the div is already a message; if not, set text now.
                 thinkingDiv.className = 'message assistant';
                 setMessageText(thinkingDiv, 'assistant', job.response || '(no response)');
                 const assistHistIdx = currentHistory.length;

documentation/TODO__Agents.md

@@ -249,6 +249,30 @@ model costs down as sessions grow. Not continuous per-token — checkpoint-trigg
 heuristic handles the worst cases. Priority rises with dev-agent pipeline work where
 aider tool results can be very large.
 
+### [UX] Token streaming for orchestrator final response ✅ — 2026-06-16
+Text appears token-by-token while the model is generating, instead of waiting for the
+full response after "Generating response…" completes.
+
+- [x] **`llm_client.py`** — `complete()` gains `token_sink` param; `_dispatch()` routes to
+      streaming variants when set; `_anthropic_api_streaming()` uses `client.messages.stream()`;
+      `_local_streaming()` uses `httpx client.stream()` + SSE parsing; non-streaming backends
+      (claude_cli, gemini_cli) emit full text as one chunk via `token_sink`
+- [x] **`orchestrator_engine.py`** — `run()`, `_run_from_contents()`, and `_claude_handoff()`
+      all accept and thread `token_sink`; Gemini handoff to Claude/Anthropic API is the
+      primary streaming path
+- [x] **`openai_orchestrator.py`** — `run()` and `_run_from_messages()` accept `token_sink`;
+      local model final response emitted via `token_sink` (one chunk for now; true streaming
+      left for future polish)
+- [x] **`routers/orchestrator.py`** — each job gets an `asyncio.Queue` (`_event_queue`);
+      `_on_progress` and `_token_sink` write to the queue as events (`{type, text}`);
+      `_finalize_job` emits `{type: done, ...}`, error handler emits `{type: error, ...}`,
+      confirmation gate emits `{type: confirm, ...}`; new `GET /orchestrate/{job_id}/stream`
+      SSE endpoint with 20s keepalive timeout; handles already-complete/error jobs immediately
+- [x] **`static/app.js`** — `_doOrchestrate` switches from poll loop to `EventSource`; renders
+      thinking-bubble progress labels on `progress` events; converts bubble to streaming message
+      on first `token` event (with auto-scroll); handles `confirm`, `error`, `done` events;
+      finalization (metadata, history controls, tool calls) runs after `done`
+
 ### [Auth] Encrypted sessions
 Allow users to opt-in to per-session encryption so session logs on disk cannot be
 read without the user's key.